Large Bench Orders

Large Bench Orders

Matters Pending before Large Bench of AFT (PB) and RB's

Sr. No.	Case	Petitioner	Reference Order	Corum	NDOH	Remark
1	MA (Dy No. 3380/2015) in OA No. 155/2011	Air Cmde TM Rao	15.12.2015 (Order)	Hon'ble Chairperson Hon'ble Justice Anjana Mishra Hon'ble Lt. Gen. P.M. Hariz	04.08.2023
2	OA 1487/2018	JWO S K Sahay	26.02.2020 (Order)	Hon'ble Chairperson Hon'ble Justice Anjana Mishra Hon'ble Lt. Gen. P.M. Hariz		Notice issued to parties on 24.05.2023 for submission of comments.
3	OA 589/2019	Ex. Hony Nb Sub Ram Kishan	28.01.2020 (Order)	Hon'ble Chairperson Hon'ble Justice Anu Malhotra Hon'ble Lt. Gen. P.M. Hariz	12.07.2023
4	OA 2059/2021	Wg Cdr SS Gehlot	05.01.2022 (Order)	Hon'ble Chairperson Hon'ble Justice Anjana Mishra Hon'ble Lt. Gen. P.M. Hariz	23.08.2023
5	OA 548/2016 with MA 392/2016 & 393/2016	Ex Sub/SKT Achintya Das Choudhary	06.03.2019 (Order)	Hon'ble Justice Anjana Mishra Hon'ble Justice Anu Malhotra Hon'ble Lt. Gen. CP Mohanty	13.07.2023
6	OA No 86/2011 (RB Jaipur)	Smt Phul Pati W/o Ex Nb Sub Jaipal SIngh	19.07.2022 (Order)	Hon'ble Justice Anjana Mishra Hon'ble Lt. Gen. P.M. Hariz Hon'ble Lt. Gen. CP Mohanty	28.07.2023
7	OA 219/2017 with MA 169/2017 & 171/2017	CCP Nambiar Ex Chera	15.05.2018 (Order)	Hon'ble Chairperson Hon'ble Justice Anjana Mishra Hon'ble Lt. Gen. P.M. Hariz	12.09.2023	Bench constituted. To be put up after summer vacation for fixation of date.
8	MA 764/2015 in OA 414/2010	Maj Gharib Singh Bal (Retd)	25.05.2016 (Order)	Hon'ble Chairperson Hon'ble Lt. Gen. P.M. Hariz Hon'ble Vice Adm Dhiren Vig	05.09.2023	Bench constituted. To be put up after summer vacation for fixation of date.
9	OA 57/2020 with MA 55/2020 (RB Jabalpur)	No. 15368131P Hav Rajkumar (Retd)	12.04.2023 (Order)	Hon'ble Justice Anjana Mishra Hon'ble Lt. Gen. P.M. Hariz Hon'ble Lt. Gen. CP Mohanty	17.07.2023 (At 2:15 PM)	Bench constituted. To be put up after summer vacation for fixation of date.
10	OA 629/2016
11	CA 4/2014
12	RA 265/2017 in OA586/2015 (RB Chandigarh)
13	OA 29/2014
14	RA 1/2020 with MA 58/2020 in OA 228/2012
15	RA 3/2020 with MA 212/2020 in OA 965/2017
16	OA 828/2020			Hon'ble Justice Anu Malhotra Hon'ble Lt. Gen. P.M. Hariz Hon'ble Lt. Gen. CP Mohanty

Judgements Delivered by the Large Bench of AFT (PB) and RB's

Sr. No.	Case	Petitioner	Reference Order	Corum	Date of Judgement	Remark
1	OA 471/2010	Hav Parmeshwar Ram Vs. UOI & Ors.		Hon'ble Mr Justice A. K. Mathur, Chairperson, Hon'ble Mr. Justice S. S. Kulshreshtha, Judicial Member and Hon'ble Lt. Gen. M. L. Naidu, Administrative Member	19.10.2020 (Order)	Transferred to RB, Jaipur, vide order dt 19.10.2010
2	OA 279/2011,etc	Nb Sub Roshan Lal Vs. UOI & Ors.	Reffered, vide order dated 06.09.2012 in OA 279/2011	Hon'ble Mr Justice A. K. Mathur, Chairperson, Hon'ble Mr. Justice N. P. Gupta, Judicial Member & Hon'ble Lt. Gen. S.S. Dhillon, Administrative Member	03.01.2013 (Order)
3	OA 11/2014	Maj Gen (Retd) Tej Krishnan Kaul Vs.& Ors.	Referred, vide order dated 3.2.2014 in OA 11/2014	Hon’ble Mr Justice Sunil Hali,Judicial Member, Hon’ble Mr Justice R.C.Mishra, Judicial Member and Hon’ble Air Marshal J.N.Burma, Administrative Member.	07.08.2014 (Order)
4	OA 228/2012, etc	Sub Lakshmi Kant Mishra, etc. Vs. UOI & Ors	Rererred, vide order dated 23.07.2013 in OA 228/2012	Hon’ble Mr Justice Prakash Tatia, Chairperson, Hon’ble Mr Justice Sunil Hali, Judicial Member and Hon’ble Lt. Gen. S.K. Singh, Administrative Member.	24.09.2014 (Order)
5	OA 483/2013,etc	Lt Gen (Retd) SS Dahiya, etc. Vs. UOI & Ors.		Hon’ble Mr Justice Prakash Tatia, Chairperson, Hon’ble Mr Justice Sunil Hali, Judicial Member and Hon’ble Lt. Gen. Sanjiv Langer, Administrative Member	24.07.2015 (Order)
6	OA 201/2014	Ex Hav Jahen Singh Vs UOI & Ors		Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sunil Hali, Jucicial Member PB, Hon’ble Mr. Justice R.C. Mishra, Judicial Member PB and Hon’ble Air marshal J.N. Burma, Administrative Member.	15.12.2015 (Order)
7	OA 460/2015	Capt Gunutuboina Vivekanand Vs. UOI & Ors.	Referred, vide order dated 21.07.2015 in MA 516/2015 & MA 533/2015 in OA 460/2015	Hon’ble Mr. Justice Prakash Tatia, Chairperson, Hon’ble Mr. Justice S. S. Thakur, Judicial Member, AFT, RB, Chandigarh and Hon’ble Lt. Gen. Sanjiv Langer, Administrative Member.	11.09.2015 (Order)
8	OA 590/2014,etc	Col Ashok Mishra, etc. Vs. UOI & Ors.	Referred, vide order dated 12.12.2014 in MA 753/2014 in OA 590/2015	Hon’ble Mr. Justice Prakash Tatia, Chairperson, Hon’ble Mr. Justice S. S. Thakur, Judicial Member, AFT, RB, Chandigarh and Hon’ble Lt. Gen. Sanjiv Langer, Administrative Member.	24.04.2014 (Orders)
9	OA 1439/2016, etc	Ex Sgt Girish Kumar, etc. Vs. UOI & Ors.		Hon’ble Mr Justice Virender Singh, Chairperson, Hon’ble Mr Justice Surendra Vikram Singh Rathore, Judicial Member and Hon’ble Lt. Gen. S.K. Singh, Administrative Member	01.12.2017 (Orders)
10	OA 965/2017, OA 404/2018 & OA 655/2018	Major Gen MS Jaswal, etc. Vs. UOI & Ors.	Referred, vide order dated 28.02.2018 in OA 965/2017	Hon’ble Chairperson, Hon’ble Ms. Justice Sunita Gupta, Judicial Member & Hon’ble Lt. Gen. Philip Campose, Administrative Member.	10.05.2019 (Order)
11	OA 1238/2016 & OA 272/2018	Smt Sharma Kaur, etc. Vs. UOI & Ors.	Referred, vide order dated 08.02.2018 in OA 1238/2016	Hon’ble Chairperson, Hon’ble Ms. Justice Sunita Gupta, Judicial Member & Hon’ble Lt. Gen. Sanjiv Chachra, Administrative Member.	01.10.2019 (Order)
12	OA 17/2015, OA 55/2014, 58/2015, 66/15,72/2015, 82/2015, 105/2014, 136/2015, 256/2015 & 275/2015, 91/19,92/19,93/19,94/19,34/21,35/21,51/21, 53/21,68/21 & 84/21 (RB JAIPUR)	Kaptan Singh, etc. Vs. UOI & Ors.	(Referred by the Hon. Bench comprising Hon. Dr. Justice (Mrs) Meena V. Gomber, M (J) & Hon. Lt. Gen. VK Ahluwalia, M (A), vide order dated 08.03.2016 )	Hon. Chairperson, Hon. Ms. Justice Sunita Gupta & Hon. Lt Hen PM Hariz	28.05.2021 (Order)
13	TA 37/2009 (W.P. 12610/2008) (RB JAIPUR)	Ex. CMD (O) Shish Ram Vs. Union Of India		Ho’ble Mr. Justice Sunil Hali, Member (J) Hon’ble Dr. Justice (Mrs.) Meena V . Gomber, Member(J) Hon’ble Lt. Gen V K Ahluwalia, Member (A)	23.09.2015 (Order)
14	TA 789/2010 (RB CHANDIGARH)	Rajpal Singh Vs UOI			04.03.2014 (Order)

AFT (RB) Chandigarh

RA 265/2017 in OA 586/2015 Larger Bench Order in respect of RB Chandigarh - 29-03-2019
RA 265/2017 in OA 586/2015 Larger Bench Order in respect of RB Chandigarh - 08-03-2019

AFT (RB) Jaipur